Sample pages from When You Can’t See Your Child
Sample pages from When You Can’t See Your Child. The first part shows how the wording of professional records can change what they mean over time. The second shows how to prepare for a first hearing.
Extracts are reproduced as published, with the book’s run-in headings set as web headings. © 2026 Shaun Miskelly and Danny Miskelly. Please read how you may use this material before quoting or sharing it. The book gives general information and practical guidance and is not legal advice. Full disclaimer
How wording changes a record
From the Introduction.
The record matters
One theme will appear repeatedly throughout this book: what is written down matters.
Social workers work from records. Cafcass works from records. Solicitors prepare cases from records. Barristers receive bundles containing records. Judges make decisions using evidence contained in records.
That does not mean the written record is always wrong. It means you must understand how it is created.
Suppose a parent tells a social worker: “He frightened me during the relationship.”
The first record may accurately state: Mother reports that she was frightened by Father’s behaviour.
A later summary might say: There have been concerns regarding Father’s behaviour within the relationship.
Later still: There is a history of domestic abuse.
Those sentences do not necessarily mean the same thing. The first identifies a person making an allegation. The second describes a professional concern. The third sounds like established history. Nothing in those three sentences tells us whether a court has actually made a finding.
That distinction can become enormously important.
Your first hearing
From Chapter Ten, “The First Hearing”.
The first hearing is often nothing like people imagine. You may have spent weeks preparing evidence. You may have pages of allegations to answer. You may believe this is the moment when the judge will finally hear everything and decide who is right.
Usually, that is not what the first hearing is for. In private-law children cases, the first hearing is commonly a First Hearing Dispute Resolution Appointment , usually shortened to FHDRA . Its main purpose is to identify the issues, consider safeguarding information, see whether anything can be agreed, and decide what needs to happen next. It is often about route , not final outcome.
That distinction matters. If you arrive expecting a trial, you may leave believing nothing happened. In reality, a great deal may have happened. The court may have decided:
- what issues actually matter
- whether allegations need fact-finding
- whether Cafcass or the local authority should prepare a report
- what interim contact should take place
- what evidence needs to be filed
- when the case should return
Those decisions shape everything that follows. The judge or magistrates may have read the key documents before the hearing. Do not assume they know every detail. They may have:
- the application
- the response
- the safeguarding letter
- existing orders
- perhaps short position statements
They may not have read every message, screenshot or historic document you possess. That is normal. The purpose of the first hearing is not usually to investigate every allegation. Your job is to make the important issues easy to identify.
What the first hearing is for
Before attending, read the notice or order listing the hearing. Ask: is this a FHDRA? Is the court considering interim contact? Are allegations of harm raised? Has Cafcass produced a safeguarding letter? Has anything specific been directed before the hearing?
If you have a solicitor, ask them: what decisions are we asking the court to make today? If you are representing yourself, write the answer down. It might be interim direct contact, a Section 7 report, fact-finding directions, agreement of holiday contact, or simply directions for the next stage. Do not arrive with only a general desire to “tell the truth.” Know what decision is actually available.
Bring:
- the latest court order or hearing notice
- the application
- the safeguarding letter
- your position statement if one has been filed
- your chronology
- a short note of what you want the court to do
- any document specifically required for the hearing
Do not arrive carrying every document you have collected unless they are genuinely needed. Your filing system should allow you to find additional material if required. The aim is not to impress anybody with the size of your bundle. The aim is to know where the important information is.
Family courts deal with several cases in a day. Your hearing may not start exactly when listed. You may wait. Sometimes discussions take place outside the courtroom before the case is called — Cafcass may speak with the parties, solicitors may negotiate, proposals may be exchanged.
That time is not necessarily wasted. An agreement reached before entering court can simplify the hearing considerably. But do not allow pressure in a corridor to make you agree to something you do not understand. If a proposal is made, ask: what exactly is being proposed? Is it temporary or final? When will it be reviewed? What happens if it does not work? Will it become part of a court order? If you have a lawyer, ask for advice. If you do not understand, say so.
If part of the case can be agreed, agree it. Do not reject a sensible proposal merely because it came from the other parent.
Suppose you want alternate weekends plus a midweek overnight. The other parent agrees alternate weekends but not the midweek stay. You have narrowed the dispute. That is useful. The court now needs to consider one remaining issue rather than the entire arrangement. Agreement reduces the number of things that strangers need to decide about your child. That is usually a good thing.
There is another side to this. Do not agree to an arrangement you believe is unsafe or plainly unworkable simply because you are frightened of appearing difficult. Reasonableness does not mean saying yes to everything.
You can say: “I agree with alternate weekends but I do not agree that contact should remain supervised indefinitely. I would like the court to consider a clear review point.” That is a position. You are entitled to have one.
Safeguarding, reports and interim orders
Safeguarding information can affect what the court is prepared to order while the case is still being investigated. The judge may need to decide whether direct contact can continue, whether temporary safeguards are required and what further information is needed before a final decision can be made.
If disputed allegations are central to risk or future arrangements, the court may decide that some facts need to be determined at a later fact-finding hearing. If a broader welfare assessment is needed, it may order a Section 7 report from Cafcass or the local authority. At this first hearing you do not need to master either process; you need to understand whether it has been ordered, what it is meant to address, and what you must do next. Chapters Thirteen and Fourteen deal with those stages properly.
Interim arrangements matter because they may operate for months. If direct contact is not restored, ask what concern prevents it, what assessment or evidence is required, whether supervised or indirect contact is possible and when the position will be reviewed. Do not leave with the word interim but no idea how the case is supposed to move forward.
Representation
Do not assume you have already lost. A barrister may present the other parent’s case clearly and confidently. That is their job. Do not compete by trying to sound like a barrister. Be organised. Be accurate. Answer questions. Know your documents. Know what you want. A litigant in person who understands the case can be far more effective than one who tries to imitate legal language.
You are paying for judgment, not obedience. If your lawyer says “I do not think the judge will make that order today,” ask why. If they advise accepting a proposal, ask what the advantage and risk are. If they advise against raising an issue, ask whether it is irrelevant, premature or strategically unhelpful. You remain the client. But using a professional while ignoring their legal judgment defeats much of the point of paying them. Understand the advice before deciding.
Leave with a clear map
The end of the hearing can become confusing. The judge may speak quickly. There may be several directions — for example:
- Father to file a statement by 4pm on 12 July
- Mother to respond by 4pm on 26 July
- Cafcass to prepare a Section 7 report by 30 August
- police disclosure to be obtained
- interim contact every Saturday
- case listed for review on 14 September
Do not rely solely on what you remember the judge saying. The written order records what the court directed. When you receive it:
- read every paragraph
- check deadlines
- check contact arrangements
- check the next hearing
- check who must do what
- check whether it accurately reflects what happened
If something appears materially wrong, raise it promptly through the proper route. Do not wait until the next hearing.
Before you mentally close the day, you should know:
- what did the court decide today?
- what remains unresolved?
- what must I do, and by when?
- what must the other party do?
- what report or evidence has been ordered?
- what happens with the child in the meantime?
- when is the next hearing?
If you cannot answer those questions, find out.
Before you leave the first hearing
The most useful preparation is simple: read the safeguarding letter, know what you want the court to do today, take a short position statement if appropriate, and have the few documents needed to correct any important factual error. During the hearing, take notes rather than trying to remember everything.
Do not leave court with only an impression that the hearing went well or badly. You should know what was decided, what remains unresolved, what happens with your child in the meantime, what you must file, who else must do something, every deadline, and the purpose of the next hearing. When the written order arrives, check it against those notes.
Continue reading
Paperback on Amazon UK Kindle edition Free checklist
Support organisations, McKenzie Friends and practitioners can request a review copy.